People like to complain about AP voters, but this just goes to show that ranking teams is difficult. This is a poll composed of fans who are all big enough college football fans that they pay to listen to a (great) CFB podcast.
You have Georgia, who lost to an unranked team a week ago, at No. 3 — ahead of unbeaten UCLA and Utah. Notre Dame is ahead of BYU despite losing to them a week ago. Kentucky is ahead of Alabama because the Wildcats have one loss — an absolute pasting at the hands of Bama.
That's not to say it's "wrong." Just that you can poke holes in any ballot or poll.
After a community vote, here's your Verballer Top 12 for Week 9.
Who's too high, who's too low?