Finally got a chance to take a peak of where I got it wrong regarding Living Word Lutheran/Colby.
#wisfb
It comes down to the newly formed Catholic Central/Kenosha Christian Life Co-op. This co-op is part of the Midwest Classic (same conference as LWL). The co-op was formed outside of normal timing for creating one, so how points against them were to be counted had to be figured out.
All throughout the season on LaVoy's site and on the WIAA's mid season official standings, all games against CC/KCL were automatically given a forfeit win for the opponent, for playoff purposes. This was technically a win against a ghost Catholic Central team, which is D7.
So, Catholic Central was treated as a winless team, and that's how I was treating that as well.
Somehow, the WIAA, decided to change this interpretation on the final night of the season.
Wins over CC/KCL were now treated as a D6 win, and as a win over a team with a 1-7 record. While it may not seem like much, that is the difference between Living Word Lutheran being in, compared to Colby being in.
And why a 1-7 record? CC/KCL went 2-7 on the field and it appears their win over Johnson Creek (or even the game itself) does not exist. If that game would've been accounted for, then every team who played CC/KCL, their PQS score would be slightly higher, which could change seeds, brackets, etc.