The most prolific murderers kill during childhood but the crime is typically characterized as an accident, drowning, or fall. That Cole murdered at age 8 speaks to the intensity of his homicidal ideation even in the earliest years of life.
Carroll Cole confessed to 35 murders. All women. His killing spree ran for decades across multiple states before Nevada executed him in 1985. He claims his first kill was at age 8 - he said he drowned a boy who bullied him. The death was ruled an accident. When they finally caught him and offered him a chance to fight for his life - he told them he simply didn't care.
His mother forced him to watch her cheat on his father and threatened him into silence. He later told psychiatrists it was where his hatred of women began. He walked into those same psychiatrists' offices himself - voluntarily - described his violent impulses in detail, begged for help. They released him anyway. The bodies kept piling up.
In the video below, Carroll Cole sits down for his final interview less than 8 hours before his execution - and says something that stops the reporter cold.
Asked if he wanted to delay the execution, he said no.
Asked why he wouldn't fight for his life, he said he just didn't care to.
He showed remorse for only one victim. An 11-year-old girl from 1967. Said he thought about her for years. Condemned himself for it. Said he could imagine what her life might have been like.
The reporter asked if he deserved to die.
Cole paused. Then said yes. For what he did - yes.
He said he was a little concerned about pain. Nevada had never carried out this type of execution before. Nobody knew exactly what would happen. But it didn't change his decision.
A man who asked for help before the killing started. Who walked into a psychiatrist's office and said he was afraid of what he might do.
The system heard him. Then let him walk out the door.
Was Carroll Cole born a killer, or did everyone who could have stopped him simply look the other way?