I'm lucky to have had the chance to be inspired by Sam's clear-eyed optimism over the past couple years. Here's a message worth reading if, like me, you've found yourself questioning your place in an uncertain future with AI.
When I personally realized that AI could do much of the work that occupied me during my computer science PhD, I felt what I can only describe as a kind of depression, a sense that I had once had something of value to offer the world that was now worthless by virtue of its sheer availability. Despite those feelings, I was still so curious to test the limits of this strange new technology that I discovered that far from leaving me nothing to do, AI opened up the whole world to me. Anything I wanted to learn, anything I wanted to do suddenly seemed in reach. Soon after, I found that when used wisely, AI could be a friend and a mentor to me in times of loneliness and doubt. Ultimately I found that when I looked back, I could see AI, especially Claude, helping me become a kinder, more thoughtful person, helping me engage more deeply with life and the people around me.
Since I am an AI researcher, it was natural for me to have these feelings a little sooner than most, and as I look around me I see many people going through a similar experience, if they have not chosen denial as a coping mechanism. I believe that many people do not want a future of idleness, where all their problems are solved for them and they are left to frivolous pursuits or worse, discarded entirely. Our work is a central part of our sense of meaning and identity. And so that means that it is not enough to show that AI can solve problems, even very important ones. We have to show that there is a future for everyone in a post-AI world. We have to show that everyone has a part to play in the story we, the human race, will write together as we chart our course through history.
If you are out there wondering if there is still a place for you in the uncertain future, the answer is yes. Unequivocally yes. If you are wondering what exactly it is you will do, allow me to offer four evergreen human callings.
1. Defining human flourishing.
For the sake of argument, grant AI internal experience. Grant AI some kind of consciousness. By definition, that consciousness is not human consciousness. That means AI can never know what kind of human experience is good. That is up to us. Ultimately, that manifests as a choice of basic goods and values that we wish to design AI systems to uphold.
2. Judging execution
If we have defined the good (at least in the frame of some community), then we must ultimately judge whether the good is attained, whatever the means. If we want to build an automatic judge system, we still have to decide how that system should be built and evaluated. Ultimately the judge must be judged, and no infinite recursion of systems can get you out of this.
3. Witnessing the world
AI systems perceive a digital projection of the world. It is up to us to judge whether what the AI perceives is faithful to our perception. Alignment of perception is just as essential as alignment of values if we want AI to produce outcomes that we want to see in the world.
4. Dwelling at the frontier
The universe is a big place. There will always be an infinite frontier to explore where statistical inference breaks down simply for lack of data, and AI is at its core statistical. That is both its power and its weakness. We will always be at edge of legibility, inventing new words and leaping into the unknown simply because we find joy in it.
Do not listen to anyone who tells you that doom is inevitable. Do not listen to anyone who tells you you are powerless to change fate. Do not listen to anyone who tells you you have to abandon your values to please the markets. The markets are only a reflection of what we choose to value. Whether our children curse or bless us depends on the choices we make today. It depends on what problems we set AI to solve, and the steps we take to do so safely. We are the creators of AI, and it will be what we choose to make it. Let's make it kind. Let's make it good.