For reference, this is what this post is referring to. 2024 was especially bad with pre-season CFP hype, probably the strongest team TXST has ever had, and being favored in every single game that year.
2023 (7-5)
1) ULL - 11 point 4th quarter lead - lost 34-30
2) Troy - 10-7 lead at halftime - lost 31-13
3) Arkansas State -favored by 3.5 - lost 77-31
2024 (7-5)
1) Arizona State - favored by 2.5 - lost 31-28 - 2 drives to attempt a FG for the tie or TD to win. Ended with int and failed 4th down conversion.
2) SHSU - favored by 11 - 22 point lead early and 18 point lead midway through 3rd quarter - lost 40-39
3) ODU - favored by 10 - lost 24-14
4) ULL -favored by 4 - lost 23-17
5) Georgia State - favored by 21 - lost 52-44
2025 (6-6)
1) Arkansas State - favored by 13.5, led 30-24 with 1 minute left - lost 31-30
2) Troy - favored by 9.5, led 21-0 early and by 8 with less than 4 minutes to play - lost 41-48 in OT
3) Marshall - favored by 3.5, had 17-13 lead at half and 8 point lead in 4th quarter - lost 37-40 in OT
4) ULL - favored by 3.5 - lost 42-39
2026 (2-3)
1) Utsa - favored by 1.5, led 17-7 at half and 2 point lead with 4 minutes left - lost 31-26
2) SDSU - favored by 9.5, had 17-3 lead at the half - lost 31-29
I don't blame anyone for questioning if Kinne is the right guy for the job at this point.
It's not just 1 or 2 (utsa and SDSU) games that people are upset about. It's a developing pattern over the past 4 years.
Every single year he's been coach there have been at least 2-3 sometimes more games that we were either favored in or had big leads half way through the game or longer that we ended up losing.
If you leave 2-3 wins on the table in year 1 or year 2, then maybe you can chalk it up to a new HC learning on the job. EVERY SINGLE YEAR? That's when people justifiably start asking questions.
He's in year 5 of being a HC and year 4 at TXST. How many years do you give a new HC that same "learning on the job" excuse?
Being realistic here though, we just signed him to an expensive and lengthy contract. Kinne isn't on the hot seat right now. Not because he shouldn't be, but because we can't afford the buyout if we wanted to.