After submitting numerous
#NIH R01 grants as an ESI (from not discussed to the 2nd percentile) and serving on multiple study sections, I've gradually learned a few things:
1. Despite the randomness, the NIH study section system is still relatively fair and rigorous in its review process.
2. Quantity does not lead to quality. Submitting many mediocre grants to increase the overall chance of success simply does not work. I only need one good proposal, and I should dedicate my attention to making it work. A grant is a proposal for what I aim to accomplish over the next five years. When I think about it clearly enough, the writing comes naturally. Preparing a grant really well also helps me sort things out for the future. It helps me correct my research direction upfront and saves government money.
3. None of the LLMs are helpful in writing grants (they can only be used to polish languages). They do not reason. They hallucinate. They fabricate. And we can tell it easily (in a study section).
4. Do real science, and people will appreciate it, sometimes.
5. I'm grateful to be in an environment where, despite the uncertainty in research funding, colleagues, mentors, and the department are always supportive. It really makes a difference.
6. Celebrate every small success, and always stay positive. 🙏