economist @arbeiterkammer. research fellow @wu_vienna. phd from @thenewschool. book with güney işıkara : marx's theory of value at the frontiers.

Vienna, Austria
Publication day! Güney Işıkara's and my book "Marx's Theory of Value at the Frontiers" is out oday! We wrote a book on Marx's theory of value. Why? Because it is essential for tackling core 21st-century crises: imperialism and ecological breakdown. 🔗 routledge.com/Marxs-Theory-o…
5
36
125
12,499
Because his 1972 "humbug function" criticism of the Solow model was published as a note, not a paper, Anwar Shaikh didn't get to respond to Solow in the journal. He published an extension and reply of sorts six years later, in the 1980 book "Growth, Profits and Property".
1
2
16
447
While the paper extends the argument already presented in the RESTAT paper, it inspired a broad criticism of the aggreagte production function summarized in Felipe and McCombie's 2013 book "The Aggregate Production Function and the Measurement of Technical Change: Not Even Wrong"
2
65
Guglielmo Carchedi died two days ago. Best known to my generation for editing "World in Crisis" and coauthoring "Capitalism in the 21st Century". He was a Marxist economist, prolific, creative and analytically precise. He will be terribly missed.
GUGLIELMO (MINO) CARCHEDI, A COMMUNIST DIED… September 5, 1938 – October 29, 2026 I have lost a very close friend, a great Marxist economist. He had been struggling with Parkinson’s in recent years. After losing his beloved wife, Jose,+
1
5
34
1,192
Staying on the issue of crises, in 1978 Anwar Shaikh published a comment on Dobb's theory of crisis paper, in the Cambridge Journal of Economics he had co-founded. Maybe most importantly, he formulates fundamentals of real competition as driving falling rates of profits.
3
2
14
963
Replying to @patrickmokre
In our recent book, S. Savran and I modeled our crisis chapter, "The World in Economic Crisis: The Twilight of Capitalism," on Anwar’s article that you shared. tinyurl.com/4jz8r7jw
1
1
5
264
One can distinguish phases in Anwar Shaikh's work, but some issues appear from his first to the last contributions. One is crisis and crisis theories, on which he wrote a primer in 1978. It is still key to understanding to different understandings of crisis between economists.
3
11
48
1,335
Many early contributions of Anwar Shaikh revive and further develop basic Marxist categories. In this paper from 1977, Anwar characterizes the "transformation problem" (from labor values to production prices), provides a modern solution, and gives the deviations economic meaning.
2
12
111
3,022
1974 hat das @restatjournal ein Kapitel aus Anwar Shaikh's Dissertation als Note veröffentlicht: die berüchtigte Humbug-Produktionsfunktion. Darin zeigt Anwar, dass der empirischen Erfolg von Solows Wachstumsarithmetik eben das ist: ein algebraischer Trick.
1
2
20
740
Bis letztes Jahr hat Anwar darauf bestanden, dass die Arbeit ursprünglich ein Paper akzeptiert hatte. Das hätte ihm das Recht gegeben, auf Solows Antwort zu antworten. Nach einer Intervention sei er zur 'Note' heruntergestuft und die Debatte mit Solows Antwort beendet worden.
1
2
92
Anwars Beitrag war ein zentraler Punkt in der Neuformierung einer heterodoxen Kritik am Mainstream. Aber anders als bei den Cambridge-Kapitalkontroversen kam es zu keinem Austausch. Die Neoklassiker:innen lächelten es weg, und die Kritiker:innen zogen ihr eigenes Ding durch.
2
46
Lustige Grafik, unhaltbare Schlussfolgerung: in Europa hat Bruttorendite keinen erkennbaren Zusammenhang mit Bauaktivität von Wohneinheiten. Gerade Österreich hat hohe Fertigstellungsquote bei geringen Renditen.
Niemand sollte sich wundern, dass es in Österreich steigenden Wohnungsmangel gibt. Wenn sich Vermietung nicht rentiert, wird Kapital anders investiert. Das Ergebnis: es wird zu wenig gebaut, das Angebot an Wohnraum hält nicht mit der Nachfrage mit, die Preise steigen. Durch die dauernden Eingriffe in den Mietmarkt wird das Problem damit nur schlimmer. Die Mietpreisbremse bedeutet für Investoren schlechte Renditeaussichten, das strenge Mietrechtsgesetz macht Vermietung zusätzlich zu einem riskanten Unterfangen. Und solange die politische Klasse bei jedem Problem in die Preise eingreift, muss man als potenzieller Wohnungsbaumeister jederzeit mit noch schlechteren Bedingungen rechnen. Bei Investitionen, die oft Jahrzehnte zur Amortisation brauchen, inspiriert das keine Zuversicht.
3
11
550
In April 1973, Challenge published a primer on international money market by Anwar Shaikh. It was his first publication post-dissertation, but more importantly, demonstrates his dedication to making economic analysis available to the broader public.
1
12
83
2,022
The money system Anwar describes has changed substantially. What remains is his sharp analysis and writing style. Also, what I mean by "broader" public: Most of Anwars writing wasn't popular, but it always made knowledge approachable to groups that had previously been gatekept.
6
143
Having arrived at the #30fmm conference and it's discussions about 30 years of heyeroeox and postkeynesian thought, I read Anwar Shaikh's short paper on heterodoxy as a true alternative from 2014 again. Here he counterposes criticism of the mainstream to independent alternatives.
6
46
1,358