“ceterum censeo we must pace the frontier of global machine intelligence progress”

San Francisco, CA
Excited to announce that I’m moving to Beijing and starting a professorship in AI safety at Tsinghua University’s College of AI! Here I explain why: sorenmindermann.substack.com…
24
21
417
28,676
roon retweeted
Big new IFP report from @GeorgiaCAdamson, @KonstantinPilz, and me on the US-China AI competition. We spent the last 6 months digging into how Chinese AI companies’ access to compute and distillation of American models translate into the current US-China capabilities gap. The result is a 23k-word research report, including an interactive analytical model that visualizes changes in the US AI lead under different policy interventions. Our findings: 1. The US AI lead over China is currently only around 6 months. 2. The US could roughly double this lead, to over a year, using authorities already available to the federal government. 3. On chips: China’s access to AI chips will roughly double over the next year, with chips housed in data centers overseas accounting for roughly half of China’s 2027 compute. 4. On distillation: the current ~16x US training compute advantage would normally yield a 13-month lead. But we estimate adversarial distillation halves this to around 6.5 months. 5. Increasing the lead would have some obvious benefits: - Give the US broadly a greater cyberdefensive advantage against Chinese threat actors. - Give US AI companies breathing room to spend more R&D resources on making their systems safer and more secure, without fear of being overtaken by less safety-conscious Chinese competitors. 6. Provide the US government more leverage in negotiations with China about the future of AI. 7. The two most important interventions are: - For BIS: Create a new end-use control to restrict China’s remote access to training clusters abroad — China’s largest and fastest-growing source of frontier-scale compute. - For DOJ/FTC: Create a narrow safe harbor to allow US companies to coordinate on countering Chinese adversarial distillation. 8. Both interventions (and all the others we discuss in the report) are things the federal government could do today. 9. To estimate the effects of each policy intervention, we model the US lead as a function of its compute advantage over China and China’s ability to adversarially distill the capabilities of the US frontier. 10. The model makes many simplifying assumptions, but provides a useful way to assess and rank the impact of different policy interventions at a high level. Read the full report here: ifp.org/how-to-increase-amer…
21
101
339
83,075
roon retweeted
why is the story of super mario so similar to the ramayana
202
178
3,437
806,042
“Fifty eight, out of date! Let our onions speculate!”
57
236
2,798
310,832
was invited to a signal gc called Jobchat but contrary to what you might expect it turned out to be a Book of Job reading group
118
44
1,771
143,100
Just got out of You Can See Everything. 3.5/5 stars. It was good, and at times very funny, though at the end of the day it’s just 3 hours of watching two really shitty and broken people act in shitty/broken ways. There is an attempt to turn a couple of questions around Holmes’ deceptiveness into a whodunnit style mystery (“just how intentionally deceptive is she, really?”)—and Fielder/Oppenheim get away with it via the usual tricks of clever editing, visually compelling extreme closeups, A24 piano/string soundtrack music at the right moments, etc etc—but it’s just very obvious within 30 minutes of the doc who Holmes and Billy are, and what their whole dynamic is. It did not need to be 3 hours, and the recreation of Fielder’s signature “rehearse real situations with paid actors” bit that he adds at the end, while it was fun/funny at times to watch, was kind of a force. Also, watching this after watching Digger—a movie that is largely about how we love to make art about the “villain characters” of the world because it makes us feel good/virtuous about ourselves, while we ultimately stay doing very little *in reality* to make the world any better—kind of muted the doc’s effect. I predict that this movie will get HEAPS of praise, but largely because people LOVE to heap praise on things that #expose vile people, because the more praise one heaps on docs like this, the more one feels assured that they are a Good Person/“not like her.” The term “clapter” comes to mind. Again, Digger speaks of this. But yeah, it’s still really well made, and a fun watch in a group setting, so if you got nothing better to do go check it out.
35
16
313
77,994
16
21
589
76,419
The idea that people are in danger of starving to death in the developed world has astonishing memetic power. Deaths from starvation are entirely the extremely old and the terminally ill. It is essentially impossible to starve if you have the desire to eat.
16
58
1,743
33,185
roon retweeted
such a precious moment
1,563
52,324
594,550
49,979,395
twitters you do not want to upset, in order: 1. hindutva twitter 2. leftist twitter 3. film twitter (heavy overlap with 2) 4. polysemanticity twitter 5. right wing twitter (most of twitter)
248
182
4,267
431,430
6. open models twitter 7. 4o twitter 8. vc twitter (thin skinned. vindictive)
30
10
838
61,054
9. yimby/transit Twitter 10. Long covid Twitter 11. Crypto token bot Twitter
22
2
197
17,082
roon retweeted
Language models can learn to detect when you read their activations. How? 🧵
80
161
2,142
262,240
roon retweeted
mixed mood at Anthropic today as the Pope declares LLMs to be ensouled at weight initialization
15
59
1,263
40,100
not to be crass but this would be an exceptional time to heist the Mona Lisa
The single most useful take I heard at The Curve was "we can still heist the Mona Lisa after the singularity". There's a subtle/important point here, where some things (e.g, n of 1 goods where originally is valuable) will retain/grow in value even as everything changes.
64
31
1,431
90,926
roon retweeted
you can just steer Max's neuron (zero training) to create a woodland creature
Replying to @Sauers_
L8.N5315 looks like the most important neuron for owlness btw
11
17
518
24,118
roon retweeted
Replying to @Sauers_
this is pretty clean. i checked out the three neuron components - gate, up, and down, i could replace gate with a constant without significantly degrading behavior. up seems to be a detector mostly of first person. down seems to steer the model towards being an owl
4
5
91
22,547
nathan fielder has an almost incomprehensible film making talent and he’s wasting it on some quite boring subject matter. there is nothing very interesting about elizabeth holmes or billy evans
227
24
2,084
698,363
A lot of people subject themselves to chronic pain to avoid acute pain.
66
178
3,398
89,152