I genuinely don’t know which category I fall into. I’m an independent journalist who expresses opinions, often very strongly. I don’t agree with many of your points. For example, “some mainstream journalists have failed to uphold the truth.” SOME of them? Please say MOST of them. I would say 99%, including your colleagues. I don’t follow you because I don’t watch your Godi media channel, so I don’t know much about your journalism. But you work for one, so I guess I can take the liberty of painting you with the same brush.
I quit mainstream media because I can’t see myself working for any of these channels. My idea of journalism is about pursuing the truth, not making money at any cost. Now I work independently. I shoot videos, edit them and publish them, all by myself. Sometimes, if a friend is free, I ask them to tag along and help me with the camera. But these days, I can’t even do that because they are at a greater risk of being detained. I do field reporting with whatever little resources I have. I want to do more but can’t, and even then, I feel guilty about not doing enough.
When I see something wrong, I can’t stop myself from calling it out. I’m a human being first and a journalist second. If I see the police brutally assaulting a protester in front of me, I’ll ask them why they are doing it, even if there’s a risk they might hurt me too. If Hindutva goons threaten protesters, I’ll call them out and ask the police why they are allowing it. And I have actually done something similar in the recent past. If I see a group beating up someone helpless, I can’t just stand there and watch, no matter how scary things get. I’m no activist, but journalism, in its truest sense, does have an activist dimension. If it didn’t, people like Gauri Lankesh wouldn’t have had to pay with their lives.
I studied at two of India’s top journalism institutes and took my media ethics classes seriously. I was an excellent student, and perhaps my education and empathy have made me too much of an idealist. And despite all the advice from well-wishers, I haven’t been able to change. I could make a fair amount of money if I sold my soul. I have had opportunities, and I don’t come from money, but I still can’t bring myself to compromise. My integrity is the most valuable thing I have. I haven’t earned a single rupee from my independent journalism yet. I have funded it all myself, and it’s getting harder to sustain, but I still struggle to ask for help.
So, does all this make me a journalist, or am I just some random YouTuber?
Yes, some content creators picked up a mic and became journalists. But can we blame them all? Some without journalism degrees are doing a far better job than many veteran journalists. Perhaps the real question is: why are they doing the job you were supposed to do? From what I gather, your definition of journalism suggests that speaking up against injustice or questioning power makes you an activist. So what are journalists supposed to do? Remain mute spectators?
Of course, plenty of people enter the field just to get viral footage, with little understanding of the responsibility that comes with it. And there are independent Godi media journalists too, some of whom pretend to be genuine until they establish their brand and then show their true colours. (Hey
@Abhinavpinch, sup?) If you call them out, I’ll gladly raise my voice alongside yours.
I don’t know exactly what you meant by your definitions, but since we are all defining things here, I couldn’t help defining a few things for you too.