I will read the book, but it is extraordinary to say that the withdrawal from Afghanistan was as spectacular an own goal as the current war with Iran.
As Phil Gordon points out in the review, there was no stable equilibrium to preserve in Afghanistan — only a war that the U.S. side was losing, and with greater effort could have at best lost more slowly, causing only more death and waste:
“Bergen is highly critical of [the withdrawal] decision and argues that even a force of only 2,500 U.S. troops, along with twice as many Europeans, contractors, and the Afghan National Security Forces, would have been enough to ‘hold off the Taliban.’ But this critique overlooks the fact that the Taliban had been refraining from attacks on U.S. forces only because Trump had committed in 2020 to pull them all out. If Biden had abandoned that commitment and stayed in Afghanistan, the Taliban would certainly have resumed their military offensive, and the Afghan army might have collapsed anyway in the long run. That would have meant extending the U.S. war in Afghanistan into its third decade and draining scarce resources even as the United States dealt with other major conflicts in Europe and the Middle East. And then Biden’s successor would have been faced with the familiar choice between ordering a further surge of forces or risking military defeat.”
ALL THE PRESIDENTS' WARS is the subject of a review essay in the new issue of Foreign Affairs. The reviewer, Phil Gordon, does a thorough, fair, and well-informed job of encapsulating the book's arguments.
Gordon and I differ a bit on the necessity of the Afghan withdrawal, which, in my view, was as much a spectacular our own goal as the Iran War is today, but Gordon describes the book as variously "deeply reported"and "gripping" and ends the review thusly: "Every citizen--and especially those who will make U.S. policy in the future--should reckon with the primary lesson of All the Presidents' Wars: that legitimate fears and a quest for absolute security can lead a great power to overreach, with consequences no one can predict or easily reverse."
foreignaffairs.com/reviews/w…